As software development has evolved to meet ever-changing business landscapes, Agile methodologies have burgeoned as the prized solution in modern technology landscapes. Agile approaches, such as Scrum, emphasize flexibility, collaboration, and responsiveness to change. Architecture within Agile is not static; it evolves throughout the development process, meeting the team’s needs as the project progresses. Here we will detail three critical design principles that squarely influence Agile architecture considerations for projects taking up Advanced Certified Scrum Developer (A-CSD) exams.
1. Simplicity and Evolutionary Design
A primary tenet of Agile methods is to prioritize simplicity and create an evolutionary design that can be easily modified. The architecture should be as simple as possible and must include only what is necessary to meet current user stories or requirements.
The Agile Manifesto reiterates the principle: “Simplicity — the art of maximizing the amount of work not done–is essential.” In direct terms, this principle encourages developers to circumvent over-engineering or predicting future needs that may never materialize. Stick to solving the problem at hand and build for present, confirmed requirements.
For example, consider an online shopping app feature that recommends products based on users’ past purchases. In the initial stages, the architecture should primarily focus on basic product recommendations rather than introducing complex machine learning algorithms for personalized recommendations. As the system evolves and the need arises, the architecture can then be adapted to accommodate more sophisticated features.
2. High Cohesion and Low Coupling
One of the central principles that guide Agile architecture considerations revolves around maintaining high cohesion and low coupling. Cohesion refers to how closely the responsibilities of a module or class are related to each other, while coupling is the degree to which a class or function depends on others.
High Cohesion ensures that each module in your system is self-contained and responsible for a specific feature or functionality. This principle facilitates easier understanding, modification, and testing of specific components.
Low Coupling, on the other hand, advocates for minimizing dependencies between different components of your system. This allows components to be changed or updated without triggering a cascade of alterations in the entire system.
The table below illustrates how Cohesion and Coupling interact:
| High Cohesion | Low Cohesion | |
|---|---|---|
| High Coupling | Difficult to maintain and adapt | Very complex, brittle architectures |
| Low Coupling | Ideal Scenario: Components are easy to understand, test, and modify | Some complexity, but can still lead to flexibility |
3. Emergent Architecture
Emergent Architecture is the principle where the software architecture emerges incrementally and iteratively during the development process based on actual project requirements, rather than being defined upfront.
In traditional development approaches, the entire system architecture is often preplanned, allowing little room for adjustments as the system development advances. Contrary, the emergent architecture approach enables the structure to evolve as the team better understands the problem they are solving.
For instance, in an IoT-based home automation system, you may initially assume that a simple, centralized system would sufficiently manage all devices. However, as development progresses, you realize that a decentralized, microservices-based architecture provides a better solution. In such cases, Agility helps by allowing the architecture to evolve organically, avoiding unnecessary or non-optimised complexities early in the design.
In Conclusion
In conclusion, Agile architecture considerations prioritize simplicity, high cohesion, low coupling, and emergent structures. These principles do not only ensure an architecture that is easier to understand, modify, and maintain, but also one that evolves organically to accommodate changes and constantly aligns with project objectives. Understanding these principles is essential for any aspiring Advanced Certified Scrum Developer (A-CSD), as they have a fundamental impact on how Agile projects are planned and executed.
Practice Test
Agile Architecture is independent of Agile methods and principles. True/False.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: Agile Architecture is highly dependent on Agile methods and principles, and they are integrated to ensure efficient software delivery and sustainability.
In agile architecture, the principle of focus is on achieving customer satisfaction. True/False.
- True
- False
Answer: True.
Explanation: An important aspect of Agile Architecture is that it is customer-centric. It focuses on achieving customer satisfaction by continually delivering valuable software.
The three Design principles that inform Agile Architecture considerations are: Simplicity, Flexibility and Adaptability. True/False.
- True
- False
Answer: True.
Explanation: These three principles are key to any Agile Architecture considerations, as they enable creating a design that is both easy to understand and to adapt to changing requirements.
The Agile architecture focuses more on documents rather than working software. True/False.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: In Agile, preference is given to working software over comprehensive documentation. Therefore, Agile architecture is more concerned with creating an efficient, operational software product.
Is “Evolvability” is one of the Agile design principles?
- Yes
- No
Answer: Yes.
Explanation: Evolvability is central to Agile design, considering the ongoing evolution of software requirements and technology changes.
Multiple Select: What Agile principles directly impact Agile Architecture?
- A) Self-Organizing Teams
- B) Adapt to Changes
- C) Deliver Frequently
- D) Detailed Documentation
Answer: A, B, C.
Explanation: A-C are Agile principles that impact the design and considerations of Agile Architecture, while D refers to traditional ways, which Agile sees less importance.
Simple design in Agile is characterized by avoiding possibilities of future changes. True/False.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: A simple design in Agile is characterized by how easily it can handle future changes. It doesn’t avoid future possibilities.
Patterns and guidelines are irrelevant when it comes to agile architecture considerations. True/False.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: Patterns and guidelines play a crucial role in informing agile architecture considerations. They guide how components are organized and interact with each other.
The Agile principle of “Responding to Change Over Following a Plan” has no bearing on Agile Architecture. True/False.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: This principle is significant in Agile Architecture, which promotes an adaptable and flexible design that can easily accommodate changes.
The Agile process discourages the evolution of design throughout the development process. True/False.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: The Agile process encourages the ongoing evolution of design to meet changing requirements, which is a key characteristic of Agile Architecture.
In response to a changing environment, the architecture should be rigid and fixed, according to Agile principles. True/False.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: According to Agile principles, the architecture should be flexible and adaptable, not rigid and fixed, in response to a changing environment.
Agile Architecture depends on high-quality software craftsmanship. True/False.
- True
- False
Answer: True.
Explanation: Agile Architecture requires well-crafted design and high-quality code to enable flexibility, adaptability, and simplicity.
Multiple Select: Which of the following are elements of Simplicity in an Agile design?
- A) YAGNI – You Aren’t Gonna Need It
- B) SOLID principles
- C) KISS – Keep It Simple, Stupid
- D) Agile Triangular Model
Answer: A, B, C.
Explanation: A-C are key principles that ensure simplicity. D is a principle mainly used for project management in Agile.
The Agile principle of Continuous Delivery doesn’t affect Agile Architecture. True/False.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: Continuous Delivery accentuates the need for Agile Architecture to support efficient and consistent delivery of working software.
Multiple Select: The agile architecture is mainly characterized by which of the following principles?
- A) Incremental
- B) Iterative
- C) waterfall
- D) Spiral
Answer: A, B.
Explanation: The agile architecture is characterized by being incremental and iterative, meaning that it evolves over time, adapting to changes. C and D are more attributed to traditional software development models.
Interview Questions
What is the principle of simplicity in the context of Agile architecture?
Simplicity is one of the key principles that inform Agile architecture. This principle dictates that the team should aim for the simplest architecture that can answer the current needs, rather than overbuilding to anticipate possible future needs. The architecture can be evolved as required with each iteration or release.
What is meant by the principle of ’emergence’ in Agile architecture?
The principle of ’emergence’ refers to the idea that the best architectures, requirements, and designs emerge from self-organizing teams. This principle lies at the heart of Agile thinking and encourages teams to obtain feedback early and often, adjust as necessary, and continuously improve their project through multiple iterations.
What principle informs the timing and nature of the architecture activities within an Agile project?
The principle ‘evolutionary design’ informs the timing and nature of architecture activities within an Agile project. This includes continuous refactoring, simple design, and test-first practices. It acknowledges that the system’s design evolves over time with changes made in each increment.
How does the principle of ’empowerment’ apply to Agile architecture?
The principle of empowerment is extremely important in Agile architecture. It refers to the empowerment of development teams to make design decisions. Development teams require sufficient authority, knowledge, and skills to make these decisions which leads to better quality, more sustainable designs.
Explain how the principle of ‘respect for the rhythm of the system’ relates to Agile architecture?
‘Respect for the rhythm of the system’ in Agile architecture means that team members understand and respect the existing systems and constraints and work harmoniously with them. While there will be opportunities to change, upgrade or replace parts of the system, understanding the “rhythm” or pace of change that the system can accommodate without undue disruption is crucial.
What does the principle ‘quality-driven’ refer to in Agile architecture?
‘Quality-driven’ principle in Agile architecture means that the focus should be on maintaining high quality, rather than rushing to deliver something quickly at the expense of quality. Quality considerations should be integrated into all aspects of the system’s architecture.
How is ‘collaboration’ a principle in Agile architecture?
The ‘collaboration’ principle in Agile architecture facilitates frequent interaction and cooperation between all members of the project team, including stakeholders. This helps in sharing knowledge, aligning with the needs of the business, and making collective decisions to achieve optimal architecture.
Explain how ‘incremental change’ is a design principle informing Agile architecture?
‘Incremental change’ is crucial to Agile architecture, emphasizing that changes to the system should be made incrementally, not in one fell swoop. By working in small, manageable increments, teams can more effectively manage risk, easily adapt to changes, and provide faster feedback and learning.
Why is ‘sustainability’ an important principle in Agile architecture?
The ‘sustainability’ principle in Agile architecture refers to the idea that the pace, process, and technical practices should be such that the team can maintain indefinitely. The system should be sustainable in the long term without causing significant disruptions. This involves considerations about maintainability, issue tracking, and documentation.
What is the principle of ‘face-to-face communication’ in Agile architecture?
The principle of ‘face-to-face communication’ in Agile architecture stresses that conversation is the most effective way of conveying information. This direct form of communication can limit misunderstandings, decrease delay in feedback, and promote a shared understanding of the architecture among all team members.
extutorials.com