Network Address Translation (NAT) is an essential aspect of networking that anyone preparing for the AWS Certified Solutions Architect – Associate (SAA-C03) exam needs to understand. It’s particularly crucial for those who want to craft highly scalable, high-performance architectures on AWS. Here we’re going to compare the costs of NAT instances with NAT gateways, two alternatives that AWS provides for enabling instances in a private subnet to access the Internet.
NAT Instances
NAT instances, in AWS, are regular Amazon Elastic Compute Cloud (Amazon EC2) instances that have been configured to perform NAT. They allow instances in a private subnet to access the internet or other AWS services, but prevent the internet from initiating a connection with those instances.
Let’s get more specific about the cost for running a NAT instance. EC2 instance cost depends mainly on two factors: instance type (which determines the hardware of the host computer) and the region where it will be running. For instance, as of January 2022, in the North Virginia region, an instance type t2.micro costs approximately $0.0116 per hour. Remember, you also have to consider the cost for AWS data transfer and possible Amazon EBS usage, as the instance will route traffic from your VPC to the Internet.
NAT Gateways
In comparison, a NAT gateway is a managed NAT service provided by AWS. It offers better bandwidth, availability, and durability than a NAT instance. A NAT gateway supports up to 45 Gbps of bandwidth and automatically scales based on the workload. Similarly, it is highly available within an availability zone (AZ), and AWS automatically replace the gateway if it fails.
For NAT gateways, AWS calculates cost based not only on an hourly usage rate but also on data processing and data transfer chargers. For example, in the North Virginia region, the hourly charge is approximately $0.045, plus data processing ($0.045 per GB processed) and data transfer out (at Internet Data Transfer Out rates).
Comparison
Both NAT instances and gateways have their usage based on your architecture and budget needs. If purely cost-based, a NAT instance may be more cost-efficient, especially for smaller data requirements. However, a NAT gateway’s benefits lay in its high availability, durability, and bandwidth capabilities, which justify its costs for high-traffic or critical setups.
| NAT Instance | NAT Gateway | |
|---|---|---|
| Hourly Cost | Varies | $0.045 |
| Data Processing Cost | On Data Transfer | $0.045 per GB |
| Availability | Manual setup | High (within AZ) |
| Automatic Scaling | No | Yes |
| Bandwidth | Up to 5 Gbps | Up to 45 Gpbs |
It’s also worth mentioning that the maintenance effort for a NAT gateway is lower compared to a NAT instance. With NAT instances, you would need to manage the individual EC2 instances, including tasks such as patching, updates, and monitoring, while NAT gateway is a fully managed service, thus reducing operational overhead.
In conclusion, your choice between a NAT instance and a NAT gateway might depend on your specific use case, your budget, and the amount of administrative overhead you can tolerate. When preparing for the AWS Certified Solutions Architect – Associate (SAA-C03) exam, understanding these details can help you solve scenarios and architect solutions effectively.
Practice Test
True or False: NAT gateways help to enable instances in a private subnet to connect to the internet or other AWS services but prevent the internet from initiating a connection with those instances.
- True
- False
Answer: True
Explanation: NAT gateways are designed specifically to control internet traffic to EC2 instances, thus preventing unwanted initiation from the internet.
Single Select: Which is more cost-efficient: NAT instances or NAT gateways?
- A) NAT instances
- B) NAT gateways
Answer: A) NAT instances
Explanation: NAT instances are generally more cost-efficient as they do not incur costs for data processing, unlike NAT gateways.
Multiple Select: What are the advantages of using NAT gateways compared to NAT instances?
- A) Scalability
- B) Threat management
- C) High bandwidth
- D) Integration with AWS services
Answer: A) Scalability, C) High bandwidth
Explanation: NAT gateways have in-built redundancy and high bandwidth, making them scalable. While NAT instances can integrate with AWS services, NAT gateways do not directly provide threat management.
True or False: NAT instances require a higher level of management effort compared to NAT gateways.
- True
- False
Answer: True
Explanation: NAT instances often require more manual setup and management compared to NAT gateways.
Single Select: Who is responsible for patch management in NAT instances?
- A) AWS Support
- B) AWS System Operations
- C) AWS User
- D) NAT instance provider
Answer: C) AWS User
Explanation: In the context of NAT instances, the AWS user is responsible for patch management.
True or False: You cannot create a NAT gateway in a VPC that has dedicated tenancy.
- True
- False
Answer: False
Explanation: You can create a NAT gateway in a VPC with dedicated tenancy.
Multiple Select: Which of the following are benefits of using NAT gateways?
- A) High availability
- B) Increased control
- C) Maintenance freedom
- D) Increased costs
Answer: A) High availability, B) Increased control, C) Maintenance freedom
Explanation: NAT gateways provide high availability, increased control, and reduce maintenance efforts. However, they involve higher costs compared with NAT instances.
True or False: NAT gateways charge you for data processing and data transfer out.
- True
- False
Answer: True
Explanation: Yes, with NAT gateways, you’re charged for each hour that the gateway is provisioned and available, and data processing and data transfer out costs.
Single Select: Can NAT gateways be used for one-to-one NAT?
- A) Yes
- B) No
Answer: B) No
Explanation: NAT gateways cannot be used for one-to-one NAT. They are only used for one-to-many NAT.
True or False: To use NAT gateways, you need to have an internet gateway attached to your VPC.
- True
- False
Answer: True
Explanation: An internet gateway associated with your VPC is required to route traffic to the internet from the NAT gateway.
Multiple Select: What kind of traffic is routed to a NAT gateway?
- A) Traffic from instances in a private subnet
- B) Traffic from the internet to private instances
- C) Traffic to AWS services
- D) All of the above
Answer: A) Traffic from instances in a private subnet, C) Traffic to AWS services
Explanation: NAT gateways route traffic from instances in a private subnet and traffic to AWS services, but do not route incoming traffic from the internet.
Interview Questions
What is a NAT gateway in AWS?
In AWS, a NAT (Network Address Translation) gateway is a service that enables instances in a private subnet to connect to the internet or other AWS services. However, it prevents the internet from initiating a connection with those instances.
Can you list the primary differences between a NAT instance and a NAT gateway?
Yes, the main differences include:
1. NAT Gateway is highly available within an AWS Availability Zone and scalable, while a NAT instance has to be manually managed.
2. NAT Gateway doesn’t require patch management, whereas a NAT instance does.
3. NAT Gateways support burstable performance up to 45 Gbps, whereas NAT instances offer limited throughput.
How does the cost structure differ between a NAT instance and a NAT gateway?
NAT Gateways are charged based on how much data actually moves through the gateway, whereas NAT Instances are charged based on how long they’re running, regardless of how much data is transferred.
How do NAT Gateways improve network availability compared to NAT instances?
AWS manages NAT gateways, ensuring that they remain operational and available. This is not the case with NAT instances, where handling failovers requires manual intervention and monitoring.
Is it possible to send traffic to a NAT gateway from a subnet route table?
Yes, you can do that by adding a route to the main route table that points all traffic (0.0.0.0/0) to the NAT gateway.
Compared to a NAT instance, what are the performance benefits of a NAT Gateway?
A NAT Gateway provides greater bandwidth compared to a NAT instance and supports burstable performance up to 45 Gbps.
Can NAT instances and NAT gateways be used interchangeably?
It depends on your needs. But in general, for a scalable, managed solution, the NAT Gateway is recommended over a manually managed NAT instance.
Can a NAT Gateway be associated with security groups?
No, security groups are not associated with NAT Gateways. Instead, you can apply security groups to the resources behind them.
Can a NAT Gateway span multiple availability zones?
No, a NAT Gateway cannot span across multiple availability zones.
What types of IP addresses do NAT Gateways support?
NAT Gateways support both IPv4 and IPv6 addresses.
Do NAT Gateways support Port Address Translation (PAT)?
Yes, NAT Gateways support PAT, it means a NAT gateway performs network address translation for devices in a VPC, and automatically translates the IP addresses of devices in the private subnet to the IP address of the NAT gateway when the devices access the Internet.
extutorials.com