When preparing for the AWS Certified SysOps Administrator – Associate (SOA-C02) exam, a clear understanding of the concepts of horizontal scaling and vertical scaling is paramount. Scaling is a crucial aspect of managing cloud resources and involves readjusting your system resources to meet varying workloads.
These two types of scaling allow you to effectively manage traffic, optimize performance, and efficiently utilize resources. This post will delve into what horizontal and vertical scaling are, illustrate the differences between these scales, and provide examples.
What is Horizontal Scaling?
Horizontal scaling, also known as “scaling out,” involves adding more nodes to, or removing nodes from a system in response to workload changes. Essentially, horizontal scaling implies the addition of more machines or setting up a distributed environment to spread the workload.
For instance, consider an application server cluster that contains three servers. When workload increases, instead of upgrading the servers to handle the increased load, you add more servers into the cluster. This is horizontal scaling.
AWS services that benefit from horizontal scaling include Amazon EC2, where you can add or remove EC2 instances, and Amazon RDS, where you can create a read replica to absorb read traffic.
What is Vertical Scaling?
Vertical scaling, often termed as “scaling up,” is the process of adding more power to an existing node. This usually means upgrading the hardware capabilities of an individual server, such as increasing its CPU, RAM, or storage capacity.
As an example, if you have an application running on an AWS m5.xlarge instance and the application workload increases, instead of adding more instances, you upgrade your instance to a more powerful instance type like m5.2xlarge.
Vertical scaling is common with RDS where one can change the instance type to manage an increase in workload.
Key Differences Between Horizontal Scaling and Vertical Scaling
- Nature of Scale: Horizontal scaling involves adding more machines to balance the load (scaling out), while vertical scaling involves increasing the capacity of a single machine (scaling up).
- Impact on Application: Horizontal scaling can allow your applications to handle increased traffic load without endangering the server’s performance. Vertical scaling, however, can risk overburdening the server and subsequently lead to performance issues.
- Flexibility: Horizontal scaling is more flexible as it allows adding and removing resources based on demand. In contrast, vertical scaling is a one-time action that may require downtime while the resources get upgraded.
- Cost: The cost varies: vertical scaling may initially seem cost-effective but can become expensive as you keep upgrading. With horizontal scaling, costs can be managed by effectively scaling in and out based on demand.
- Limit: Vertical scaling has a limit determined by the maximum capacity of a single machine. On the other hand, horizontal scaling can continue expanding by adding more machines.
| Horizontal Scaling | Vertical Scaling |
|---|---|
| Scale out | Scale up |
| Increase in the number of nodes | Increase in resources of a single node |
| More flexible, enables easy addition and removal of resources | Less flexible, may require downtime during an upgrade |
| Typically more expensive | Initially less expensive, but cost of hardware upgrades may escalate |
| Virtually limitless, subject to the number of machines that you can add | Performance limit is determined by the capacity of a single machine |
In conclusion, both horizontal and vertical scaling have their advantages and use cases. Choosing between horizontal and vertical scaling strategies would largely depend on your application workload and architecture. It is essential to understand these scaling strategies to make informed decisions during your AWS SysOps administration tasks.
Practice Test
True/False: Horizontal scaling is the practice of adding more computing resources to handle increased network traffic.
- True
- False
Answer: True
Explanation: Horizontal scaling indeed refers to the practice of adding more hardware or network resources to handle increased traffic or data processing needs.
Which of the following is another term for horizontal scaling?
- A. Scale up
- B. Scale sideways
- C. Scale down
- D. Scale out
Answer: D. Scale out
Explanation: Scale out is another term for horizontal scaling, which refers to increasing system capacity by adding more hardware or network resources.
Vertical scaling refers to:
- A. Increasing the processing power of an existing server
- B. Decreasing the processing power of an existing server
- C. Adding more servers to the system
- D. Both A and C
Answer: A. Increasing the processing power of an existing server
Explanation: Vertical scaling, also known as scaling up, refers to boosting the capacity of existing hardware or software by adding resources.
True/False: In horizontal scaling, data consistency is easier to achieve than in vertical scaling.
- True
- False
Answer: False
Explanation: Typically, horizontal scaling brings challenges in data consistency and complexity because data has to be distributed among various nodes/servers.
Which of the following is a potential disadvantage of vertical scaling?
- A. It can lead to wastage of resources
- B. It has a limit to the extent of scale
- C. It can cause network congestion
- D. It is more costly
Answer: B. It has a limit to the extent of scale
Explanation: Vertical scaling is constrained by the fact that there is an upper limit to the amount of resources that can be added to a single machine.
What is the difference between horizontal and vertical scaling?
- A. In horizontal scaling, you add more resources to your server, while in vertical scaling, you add more servers.
- B. In vertical scaling, you add more resources to your server, while in horizontal scaling, you add more servers.
- C. There is no difference
- D. Both A and B.
Answer: B. In vertical scaling, you add more resources to your server, while in horizontal scaling, you add more servers.
Explanation: Vertical scaling involves adding more power (CPU, RAM, disk capacity) to an existing machine. Horizontal scaling means adding more machines to the existing pool (like adding more servers to the web farm).
True/False: Vertical scaling requires your applications to be distributed across multiple servers.
- True
- False
Answer: False
Explanation: Vertical scaling does not require applications to be distributed. It adds more power to a single server. Horizontal scaling requires distribution.
Which of the following is necessary for horizontal scaling?
- A. Load balancers
- B. More RAM
- C. Faster CPU
- D. More Disk space
Answer: A. Load balancers
Explanation: For horizontal scaling, load balancing is necessary to distribute network or application traffic across a number of servers.
True/False: AWS provides services like Auto Scaling groups for both horizontal and vertical scaling.
- True
- False
Answer: True
Explanation: AWS provides services like Auto Scaling groups which can automatically scale your application vertically and horizontally according to conditions you specify.
In AWS, vertical scaling requires _____ while horizontal scaling requires _____.
- A. more servers, more resources
- B. more resources, more servers
- C. load balancers, more disk space
- D. more CPU, more RAM
Answer: B. more resources, more servers
Explanation: Vertical scaling in AWS involves increasing the resources of an existing server, while horizontal scaling involves adding more servers. This action increases the capacity to cater to network traffic and data processing.
True/False: Horizontal scaling is generally more expensive than vertical scaling.
- True
- False
Answer: False
Explanation: While the cost can depend on many factors, generally, vertical scaling is often more expensive. Due to the physical constraints and increased cost of high-performance components, investing in a single, extremely powerful server can be more costly compared to buying multiple, less-powerful servers for horizontal scaling.
Which of the following is more suitable for applications with a large amount of data and traffic?
- A. Horizontal Scaling
- B. Vertical Scaling
- C. Both are equally suitable
- D. None of the above
Answer: A. Horizontal Scaling
Explanation: Horizontal scaling is more suitable for applications with large amounts of data and traffic, as it allows the system to distribute the load across various servers or nodes. This can help in maintaining system performance and stability.
True/False: MySQL Read Replicas is an example of horizontal scaling.
- True
- False
Answer: True
Explanation: MySQL Read Replicas is a service that allows you to offload read traffic from your source database to one or more read replicas. This is an example of horizontal scaling, as it adds more nodes to manage increased traffic.
True/False: Vertical scaling is more flexible than horizontal scaling.
- True
- False
Answer: False
Explanation: Horizontal scaling is more flexible as it offers the ability to scale dynamically based on specific needs and traffic patterns, whereas vertical scaling is limited by the inherent limits of adding more resources to a single server.
Increasing an EC2 instance’s size (CPU, RAM) in AWS is an example of:
- A. Horizontal Scaling
- B. Vertical Scaling
- C. Load Balancing
- D. Elastic Scaling
Answer: B. Vertical Scaling
Explanation: Vertical scaling involves adding more power (CPU, RAM, etc) to an existing server or node. Thus, increasing an EC2 instance’s size is an example of vertical scaling.
Interview Questions
What is the fundamental difference between horizontal scaling and vertical scaling?
Horizontal scaling refers to the addition of more machines into your pool of resources whereas vertical scaling refers to adding more power (CPU, RAM) to an existing machine.
In the context of AWS, what is the advantage of horizontal scaling?
Horizontal scaling allows for high levels of redundancy, which can provide a boost to the system’s fault tolerance and availability.
What are the possible disadvantages of vertical scaling?
Vertical scaling can lead to a higher risk of server overload. It may also lead to overall downtime as it requires the system to be shut down for upgrading.
Which AWS service is typically used for horizontal scaling?
AWS Auto Scaling service can be used to automatically adjust the number of Amazon EC2 instances in response to traffic patterns, effectively achieving horizontal scaling.
Does AWS EC2 support vertical scaling?
Yes, AWS EC2 supports vertical scaling by allowing you to change the instance type, which helps in increasing or decreasing the capacity of the instance.
How does horizontal scaling aid in handling increased traffic demand?
Horizontal scaling can handle increased traffic demand by adding more servers or instances to distribute the load evenly and preserve optimal performance.
Which type of scaling is achieved through Elastic Load Balancing in AWS?
Elastic Load Balancing achieves horizontal scaling by distributing incoming traffic across multiple targets, such as Amazon EC2 instances.
When should vertical scaling typically be used?
Vertical scaling should typically be used when there is a necessity to increase the power (CPU, RAM) of a machine to boost its performance for a specific task.
What is the main cost-related disadvantage of horizontal scaling as compared to vertical scaling?
Since horizontal scaling implies an increase in the number of instances or servers, it might be more expensive compared to vertical scaling which deals with upgrading a single server’s resources.
Which type of scaling—horizontal or vertical—offers the best solution for improving fault tolerance in AWS?
Horizontal scaling generally offers a better solution for improving fault tolerance as it involves adding redundancy to the system, which helps in maintaining system function even if some part fails.
When is horizontal scaling typically used in AWS?
Horizontal scaling is typically used to manage and increase capacity during peak loads efficiently, ensuring stability and avoiding degradation of application performance.
How does vertical scaling in AWS EC2 affect performance?
Vertical scaling can significantly improve a system’s performance by changing the instance type to a more powerful one, which increases the machine’s CPU, RAM, and storage capacity.
Which AWS service allows for vertical scaling?
The Amazon RDS (Relational Database Service) can be vertically scaled up by resizing the instance type.
What does it mean that vertical scaling has an ‘upper limit’?
Vertical scaling has an ‘upper limit’ because there is a maximum limit to how much you can upgrade or enhance a single server’s hardware. Once that limit is reached, no further vertical scaling can be done.
How could you combine both horizontal and vertical scaling for optimizing resources in AWS?
An efficient strategy could be to vertically scale up the instances until they reach their limit and then horizontally scale out by adding more instances to distribute the load, optimizing resources and maintaining performance.
extutorials.com