As professionals who are preparing for the Certified Scrum Developers (CSD) exam, understanding the differences between traditional and agile testing methods is crucial. It allows developers and testers to adapt to different project environments effectively. This article will discuss three fundamental differences between these testing methodologies, enhancing your understanding as you’re studying for the above-mentioned examination.
1. Timing of Testing:
In a traditional testing approach, testing occurs after the development phase, acting as a separate stage of the software development lifecycle (SDLC). On the other hand, agile testing is a concurrent process, closely integrated with development throughout the entire SDLC.
For instance, in a traditional Waterfall model, developers would complete coding before testing begins. Issues uncovered during testing could necessitate a complete rework of the code, wasting time and effort.
However, in an agile model like Scrum, testing occurs in every iteration (sprint) alongside development. Developers and testers constantly communicate, enabling earlier detection of potential problems and allowing for incremental development of high-quality software.
2. Scope of Testing:
The traditional testing approach primarily validates the final product, often focusing on finding flaws at the tail end of the SDLC. In contrast, agile testing checks and ensures both the product’s functionality and the process that creates it.
For example, in a traditional setup, testers might spend weeks scrutinizing a fully developed feature, looking for any bugs or defects. If any issues are discovered, they are sent back to the developers to rectify before moving on to the next feature.
In an Agile setup, however, developers and testers would work on smaller user stories within a sprint. Testers are part of the conversation from the onset, giving them a clearer idea of what to test. They can also give prompt feedback, minimizing the need for massive amendments.
3. Adaptability and Flexibility:
Traditional testing is a rigid, step-by-step process that requires a detailed upfront plan and does not welcome changes readily. In contrast, agile testing is flexible, embracing changes in requirements or priorities at any stage of the process.
Traditional testing might be suitable for projects where requirements are fixed and unlikely to evolve. A banking system, for instance, might follow such a method, as substantial changes can result in extensive complications.
On the contrary, agile testing adjusts to evolving requirements and priorities, making it apt for projects in dynamic business environments. An e-commerce application could utilize this approach, allowing it to promptly cater to changing consumer needs and market trends.
In Conclusion
Understanding these differences between traditional and agile testing is essential for a comprehensive approach to software development and testing. It helps developers and testers choose the most suitable method based on the project requirements and adaptability, both of which are necessary to ensure quality and efficiency in software development, which is a critical aspect of the CSD exam.
Remember, the essence of agile testing is not just about finding defects, but also about driving development, preventing problems, and ensuring that the product stays aligned with business needs throughout development.
Practice Test
True or False: In traditional testing, testing is only done after development is finished.
- True
- False
Answer: True.
Explanation: In traditional testing, also known as the Waterfall model, testing only takes place after the development phase is completed.
True or False: In Agile testing, testing comes first before the development phase.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: While Agile testing encourages early and frequent testing, it does not strictly come before development. Testing and development are concurrent activities in Agile.
In which of the following is feedback gathered and implemented quickly?
- A. Traditional testing
- B. Agile testing
Answer: B. Agile testing
Explanation: Agile testing emphasizes fast feedback loops, with new versions of software tested and feedback given quickly to continue the improvement process.
Which testing model is based more on documentation?
- A. Traditional testing
- B. Agile testing
Answer: A. Traditional testing
Explanation: Traditional testing follows a stringent documentation process whereas Agile encourages working software over comprehensive documentation.
True or False: In Agile testing, changes in requirements are difficult to accommodate.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: Agile is highly adaptable to changes while traditional testing struggles with such flexibility.
When is defect discovery majorly done in Traditional and Agile testing respectively?
- A. After the development, Simultaneously with development
- B. Before the development, After the development
- C. Simultaneously with development, After the development
Answer: A. After the development, Simultaneously with development
Explanation: Traditional testing discovers defects after development phase while Agile testing discovers them concurrently.
Which testing method has a siloed approach to roles and responsibilities?
- A. Traditional testing
- B. Agile testing
Answer: A. Traditional testing
Explanation: Traditional testing has specific roles for each phase. In Agile, the team collaborates on every task.
True or False: The traditional method is more adaptable to changes than the agile method.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: Agile methodology is built upon the principle of embracing changes for the customer’s competitive advantage.
Which testing method encourages customer collaboration?
- A. Traditional testing
- B. Agile testing
Answer: B. Agile testing
Explanation: Agile testing involves customer collaboration throughout the project, while traditional testing does not.
Which methodology’s testing is done by independent testers?
- A. Traditional testing
- B. Agile testing
Answer: A. Traditional testing
Explanation: In traditional testing, independent testers are often used, whereas in Agile testing, everyone on the team can test.
True or False: Agile testing is done only at the end of each Sprint.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: Testing in Agile is a continual process, performed concurrently with development throughout each Sprint, not only at the end.
Does Agile testing involve executing the same test cases repeatedly?
- A. Yes
- B. No
Answer: B. No
Explanation: Agile testing focuses more on exploratory testing rather than executing the same test cases repeatedly.
True or False: Only traditional testing involves automated tests.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: Both traditional and Agile testing can involve automated tests. However, automation is more commonly emphasized in Agile due to its fast-paced nature.
In which method is there a high risk of late defect discovery?
- A. Traditional testing
- B. Agile testing
Answer: A. Traditional testing
Explanation: As testing is done only after development in traditional methods, any defects are discovered much later, leading to increased risks.
True or False: Both traditional and Agile testing follow a sequential order.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: Only traditional testing follows a sequential order (Waterfall) whereas Agile is iterative and incremental+
Interview Questions
What is one of the key differences between traditional and agile testing approaches?
In traditional testing, testing is a phase that follows the development phase. Conversely, in agile testing, testing is an ongoing process that is conducted throughout all stages of the development process.
How does feedback differ between traditional and agile testing approaches?
In traditional testing, feedback is typically provided at the end of the testing phase, whereas with agile testing, feedback is given after each iteration, allowing for more immediate improvements.
What is a significant difference in the role of the tester in traditional versus agile methods?
In traditional testing, the tester’s role is more isolated, focusing only on testing after coding is complete, whereas in agile, testers are an integrated part of the development team and are involved from the beginning of the project.
How is the planning process different between the two methodologies?
In traditional testing, a detailed plan is prepared beforehand and followed strictly. However, in agile testing, planning is just-in-time, flexible, and revised as per the customer and project needs.
In terms of documentation, how does traditional testing differ from agile testing?
Traditional testing emphasizes heavy documentation, while agile testing values working software over comprehensive documentation.
How does the handling of changes differ between traditional and agile testing?
Traditional testing is less receptive to late changes in requirements, whereas changes are welcomed and accommodated at any point in agile testing.
How does the scheduling of testing tasks differ in agile testing compared with traditional testing?
In traditional testing, testing tasks are scheduled once all coding tasks are complete. In contrast, in agile testing, testing tasks are carried out concurrently with development tasks.
How does the goal of testing differ in agile and traditional models?
The primary goal of traditional testing is to ensure the software is bug-free, while the goal of agile testing is not just bug detection, but the delivery of maximum business value.
How is the emphasis on test automation different in agile testing compared to traditional testing?
Agile testing puts a much higher emphasis on test automation to support its quick feedback cycles and iterative nature, compared to traditional testing.
What is the difference in how communication is perceived in traditional versus agile testing environments?
Traditional testing tends to rely more heavily on formal documentation for communication, while agile environments prefer face-to-face conversations and collaboration.
How does the role of the customer/end-user differ in traditional versus agile testing methods?
Traditional testing generally involves less customer interaction, with the customer typically involved at the beginning and end of the project. In contrast, in agile testing, the customer or end-user is involved throughout the project, providing feedback in each iteration.
How does the definition of “done” differ in traditional versus agile testing scenarios?
In traditional testing, “done” commonly means that the product is ready for delivery, while in agile, “done” is typically defined for each iteration, meaning the feature is potentially shippable.
How is risk management handled in traditional compared to agile testing?
Traditional testing often employs a “big bang” risk management approach where all risks are assessed towards the end of the project, while agile testing promotes continuous risk management throughout.
How does the level of predictability compare between traditional and agile testing approaches?
Traditional testing operates under the assumption that projects are predictable, whereas agile testing embraces the inherent unpredictability of software development.
How does collaboration differ between traditional and agile testing models?
In traditional testing, there is lesser overall collaboration between the different teams involved in a project. On the other hand, Agile testing encourages strong collaboration among developers, testers, stakeholders, and customers for continual improvement and adapting to changes.
extutorials.com