As a Scrum Product Owner, your primary responsibility involves maximizing the value that your team delivers. To do this successfully, it’s crucial to understand and utilize different value measurement techniques. There are numerous methods to measure value, but this article will focus on three key techniques: Cost of Delay, Net Present Value, and Benefit-Cost Ratio.
I. Cost of Delay (CoD)
One of the primary techniques for measuring value in Scrum is the Cost of Delay (CoD). CoD represents a way of understanding the impact of time on the overall value of a product or feature. In essence, it quantifies the monetary value you lose every day that a project is delayed or a feature is not delivered.
To calculate CoD, you need to consider three components:
- Duration: The length of the delay
- Urgency: The speed at which the value decreases over time
- Value: The total possible value of the project or feature
The formula is:
CoD = Duration x Urgency x Value
By understanding the cost of delaying a project or feature, you can prioritize work to deliver maximum value. For instance, if launching a new feature could earn $100,000 per month and delaying it by three months could result in a loss of $300,000, you’d likely prioritize that over a feature that would only lose $50,000 over the same period.
II. Net Present Value (NPV)
Net Present Value (NPV) is another method used to measure value in a Scrum environment. This technique helps to measure the value of a future stream of profits in current value terms. NPV considers how much future revenue is worth in today’s dollars, taking into account the value of money over time (often referred to as the time value of money).
To calculate NPV, you will use the formula:
NPV = ∑ (Rt / (1+i)^t) – Co
Where:
- Rt is the net cash flow during the period t
- i is the discount rate or rate of return that could be earned on an investment in the financial markets with similar risk,
- Co is the initial investment
If the NPV of a prospective project is positive, it can be considered a good investment. So, for example, if a project requires an initial investment of $100,000 and is expected to yield $50,000 for the next three years, with a discount rate of 5%, we get an NPV value of $34,862. A positive NPV shows that the present value of the cash inflows is greater than the initial cost, meaning the project would add value.
III. Benefit-Cost Ratio (BCR)
The Benefit-Cost Ratio (BCR) is a simple, straightforward method of comparing the costs and benefits of different projects to make informed decisions. It provides an overview of the relationship between costs and benefits, thus enabling a Scrum Product Owner to prioritize projects that offer the highest value.
The formula to calculate BCR is:
BCR = Total Benefits / Total Costs
If the BCR is higher than 1.0, the project is seen as a good investment because the benefits are expected to outweigh the costs. If the BCR comes out to less than 1.0, the cost is greater than the benefit, so the project may not be a wise investment.
To sum up, understanding various value measurement techniques and knowing when to utilize them is crucial for any Scrum Product Owner. Whether you use Cost of Delay, Net Present Value, or Benefit-Cost Ratio, each technique will provide different perspectives, helping you to minimize waste, improve prioritization, and optimize value. Remember, the key is to align these techniques with your organizational context and strategic objectives. The CSPO exam will assess your understanding of these principles, making this knowledge vital for success.
Practice Test
True or False: One of the techniques to measure value in Scrum is Return on Investment (ROI).
- Answer: True.
Explanation: Return On Investment is a measure of value that shows the amount of return (or profit) an investment has generated relative to the cost of the investment.
Which of the following is NOT a technique to measure value in Scrum?
- A. Net Present Value
- B. Internal Rate of Return
- C. Cost of Delay
- D. Time-Boxed Planning
Answer: D. Time-Boxed Planning.
Explanation: Time-Boxed Planning is a method of planning and not a technique to measure value in Scrum.
True or False: Earning Value Analysis (EVA) is a method to measure value.
- Answer: True.
Explanation: Earning Value Analysis is a technique in project management for measuring the performance and progress of a project against its planned objectives.
Single Select: Which of the following techniques is used to measure the value in terms of time in Scrum?
- A. Internal Rate of Return
- B. Cost of Delay
- C. Net Present Value
- D. None of the above
Answer: B. Cost of Delay.
Explanation: The Cost of Delay is a technique used to measure and weigh the cost implications of delaying a product or feature.
Multiple Select: Choose the correct statements:
- A. Time Value of Money is a technique to measure value.
- B. Value Stream Mapping has nothing to do with value measurement.
- C. Cost-Benefit Analysis is not capable of capturing value.
- D. Relative Weighting is a technique to measure value.
Answer: A. Time Value of Money is a technique to measure value. D. Relative Weighting is a technique to measure value.
Explanation: Time Value of Money and Relative Weighting are valid methods to measure value, whereas Value Stream Mapping is a lean-management method for analyzing the current state and designing a future state.
True or False: Customer Feedback is ineffective in measuring value.
- Answer: False.
Explanation: Collecting customer feedback is crucial for measuring perceived value and for gaining insights for product improvement.
Which method measures the amount of value a feature adds to the business compared to the cost of developing it?
- A. Cost of Delay
- B. Customer Satisfaction Analysis
- C. Cost-Value Ratio
- D. Time-Boxed Planning
Answer: C. Cost-Value Ratio.
Explanation: The Cost-Value Ratio helps to measure the amount of value a feature adds to the business compared to the cost of developing it.
Multiple Select: What techniques can you use to measure value in Scrum?
- A. Net Present Value
- B. Return on investment (ROI)
- C. Internal Rate of Return (IRR)
- D. Sprint Planning
Answer: A. Net Present Value, B. Return on investment (ROI), C. Internal Rate of Return (IRR).
Explanation: Net Present Value, Return on Investment, and Internal Rate of Return are techniques to measure value, whereas Sprint Planning is not.
True or False: The Scrum Product Owner cannot use qualitative value metrics.
- Answer: False.
Explanation: Qualitative value metrics, including customer satisfaction and feedback, usability, and product quality, are often used alongside quantitative metrics.
Who are primarily responsible for evaluating the value of a product increment in Scrum?
- A. Scrum Master
- B. Development Team
- C. Product Owner
- D. Stakeholders
Answer: C. Product Owner.
Explanation: In Scrum, the Product Owner is responsible for maximizing the value of the product and the work of the Development Team. This includes evaluating the value of a product increment.
Interview Questions
What are some techniques to measure a product’s value in Scrum?
Techniques to measure a product’s value in Scrum include Relative Weighting, Kano Analysis, and the Economic Model.
Can you describe the Relative Weighting technique for measuring value?
Relative Weighting is a technique for measuring value where the Product Owner ranks the priority of each item on the product backlog. This is done by weighing the benefits and costs associated with each one, helping to determine the overall value to the business.
What is the principle behind the Kano Analysis technique for measuring value?
Kano Analysis is a technique for measuring value that categorizes the features of a product into three classes: Must-be, Performance and Attractive. The ‘Must-be’ contains the bare minimum requirements, the ‘Performance’ contains those that lead to satisfaction and dissatisfaction, and the ‘Attractive’ are the surprises that can delight customers.
How does the Economic Model technique measure value?
The Economic Model technique is used to measure value by prioritizing projects or features based on their cost-benefit analysis. This technique considers different economic variables such as return on investment, net present value, internal rate of return, and payback period.
What methodology is commonly used in the Economic Model to measure value?
The most commonly used methodology in the Economic Model to measure value is the Cost of Delay, which calculates the economic impact of delaying work on a certain backlog item.
How do you decide which technique to use when measuring the value of a product in Scrum?
The decision on which technique to use depends upon the specific context of the product, team, and organization. Things to consider could include the complexity of the product, the stability of the business environment, and the team’s familiarity with the technique.
Can you use more than one technique to measure value in a single project?
Yes, using more than one technique can provide a more balanced and comprehensive view of a product’s value. The techniques may complement each other and cover different aspects of value.
Is the Business Value Game a valid technique for measuring value?
Yes, the Business Value Game is a technique used to facilitate value estimation in an engaging and collaborative way. It allows stakeholders to negotiate the value of deliverables, leading to a shared understanding about the relative values of backlog items.
What other roles apart from the Product Owner are involved in measurement of product’s value?
Other roles involved in the measurement of a product’s value can include the Scrum Master, the development team, and key stakeholders. The Product Owner typically leads this effort but relies on input from these other roles.
Can a CSPO measure the value of product backlog items?
Yes, a Certified Scrum Product Owner (CSPO) is responsible for maximizing the value of the product, which includes measuring the value of the backlog items.
Do all these techniques give an absolute value for product backlog items?
No, not all techniques give an absolute value; some provide a relative value. Techniques such as Relative Weighting provide a rank order of backlog items rather than a specific numeric value.
In Scrum, how often is the value of a product measured?
The value of a product should ideally be measured with each Sprint, once a potentially deliverable product increment is created. This allows for frequent inspection and adaptation, which is a fundamental principle of Scrum.
Can the value measurement techniques impact the product backlog prioritization?
Yes, these value measurement techniques directly impact the product backlog prioritization. High value items are usually prioritized to be developed earlier in the project.
What technique would be best for a product with a high level of uncertainty?
In situations of high uncertainty, the Feature Buckets technique might be useful. It categorizes items into fixed, variable, discretionary, or ‘stretch’ buckets and value is estimated with each bucket in mind.
How essential is it for a CSPO to measure the value of a product?
It is crucial for a CSPO to measure the value of a product as it helps in decision making, prioritizing the work, reducing waste, and ultimately delivering maximum value to the customers and business.
extutorials.com