Implementing governance models plays a vital role in driving successful project outcomes, particularly in the field of construction. With the increasing complexity of projects, the Project Management Institute (PMI) has stressed the importance of effective governance models in its Construction Professional (PMI-CP) certification.
In the context of project management, governance refers to the framework of rules and practices by which project decisions are made, managed, and executed. A good governance model ensures that projects are strategic, well-managed, compliant, and effective in achieving their intended results.
According to PMI standards, there are several governance models that businesses can adopt to meet the unique requirements and challenges of their construction projects. Some of these models include the Portfolio, Program and Project Management model (3PMM), the Project Management Office model (PMO), and the Project Governance Framework (PGF). Each model offers its unique approach and benefits.
The Different Governance Models
- Portfolio, Program and Project Management model (3PMM): This model provides strategic alignment between an organization’s objectives and its projects. By classifying projects into portfolios and programs based on their strategic goals, businesses can efficiently manage and prioritize multiple projects simultaneously. It also allows for flexibility in resource allocation and risk management.
- Project Management Office model (PMO): The PMO model centralizes project governance, which facilitates standardized practices, better oversight, and improved project delivery. The PMO can provide a shared pool of resources, methodologies, tools, and techniques, which can promote consistency and efficiency across all projects.
- Project Governance Framework (PGF): The PGF primarily focuses on decision-making processes, roles, and accountability. By defining who can make decisions, when they can be made, and the extent of their decision-making power, proper checks and balances can be ensured, which will significantly reduce project risks and enhance overall project performance.
Best Practices for Implementing Governance Models
To implement these governance models effectively, PMI-CP suggests several best practices:
- Clear definition and articulation of roles: Who is responsible for project decision-making? What are the roles of project stakeholders and sponsors? These questions need to be clearly addressed to prevent misunderstandings and conflicts later.
- Decision-making processes: It’s essential to establish standard protocols for decision-making that include thresholds for sign-offs, escalation procedures, and review periods.
- Communication and reporting procedures: Effective, timely, and accurate communication is in the interest of every stakeholder. Standard reports and communication channels prevent misconceptions about project status and risks.
- Performance measurement: Establish performance metrics for each governance model to assess its effectiveness and understand areas that need improvement.
How a Construction Company Could Implement Governance Models
In practice, a large construction company planning to build a new commercial complex could implement the 3PMM model by categorizing the project into several programs, such as design, construction, finishing, and landscaping. Each program could further be broken down into various projects. This organized structure would help the company to manage the entire construction process efficiently.
Conclusion
To sum up, proper implementation of project governance models is crucial to the success of construction projects. It allows for better management control, reduces complexity, and enhances accountability and transparency, thereby improving project performance and aligning project outcomes with the strategic goals of the organization. Carefully selecting and implementing a suitable governance model can drive project success for construction professionals looking to enhance their project management competencies.
Practice Test
True or False: A well-structured governance model is not necessary for a construction project’s success.
- Answer: False
Explanation: A well-structured governance model is essential to drive project outcomes as it provides a framework for decision-making and appropriately manages risks and uncertainties.
What are the main components of a robust governance model? (Multiple Select)
- A) Clear roles and responsibilities
- B) Accountability
- C) Risk management
- D) Budget control
Answer: A, B, C
Explanation: A robust governance model should include clear roles and responsibilities, accountability, and risk management to effectively steer the project towards its objectives.
True or False: A governance model helps to identify and manage the risks in a project.
- Answer: True
Explanation: A key aspect of a governance model is risk management. It provides a framework to identify, assess, and manage the potential risks in a project.
What is the main purpose of implementing a project governance model in a construction project? (Single Select)
- A) To avoid conflicts among project team members
- B) To drive project outcomes by ensuring accountability, managing risks, and guiding decision-making.
- C) To make sure the project finishes on time
- D) To keep the project within budget
Answer: B
Explanation: While all of the options are true to some extent, the main purpose of a project governance model is to drive project outcomes by ensuring accountability, managing risks, and guiding the decision-making process.
True or False: In a governance model, only the project leader is accountable for the project outcomes.
- Answer: False
Explanation: In a governance model, all key stakeholders, including the project team, sponsors, and even third-party contractors or consultants can be held accountable, not just the project leader.
Who is responsible for implementing a project governance model? (Single Select)
- A) Project team
- B) Project sponsors
- C) Project manager
- D) All stakeholders
Answer: D
Explanation: While the project manager is often key in leading the implementation of a governance model, it’s the responsibility of all stakeholders to ensure it’s followed correctly.
True or False: Once a governance model has been established, it cannot be changed.
- Answer: False
Explanation: A governance model should be flexible and adaptable to accommodate changes in project scopes, resources, timelines, or risks.
Project governance models do not include which of the following components? (Multiple Select)
- A) Roles and responsibilities definition
- B) Risk management
- C) Communication strategy
- D) Personal work preferences of team members
Answer: D
Explanation: While effective teamwork is important in a project, personal work preferences of team members are typically not a part of a formal project governance model.
True or False: Project governance models can prevent project failures.
- Answer: True
Explanation: By ensuring accountability, managing risks, and guiding decision-making, project governance models can effectively prevent project failures.
Which is not a benefit of implementing a project governance model in a construction project? (Single Select)
- A) Increased transparency
- B) Enhanced decision-making
- C) Faster completion of project
- D) Improved budget control
Answer: C
Explanation: While a project governance model can aid in efficient project management, it does not guarantee a faster completion of the project. Time efficiency highly depends on other factors such as resource availability, work performance, etc.
Interview Questions
What are governance models in project management?
Governance models in project management are frameworks that provide structure and guide how a project will be managed. It involves defining the roles and responsibilities of every stakeholder and determining the approach and methodology for executing the project.
What is the main purpose of implementing governance models to drive project outcomes?
The main purpose of implementing governance models is to ensure that projects are executed in line with the organization’s strategy and goals, help prioritize resources effectively, and increase efficiency and success rates of projects.
How does project governance affect project outcomes?
Project governance greatly impacts project outcomes, as it provides a structure for effective decision making, proper communication channels and procedures, risk management strategies, and processes that align with the project’s goals and objectives.
Can you name a few elements of a governance model that can influence a project’s outcome?
Yes, these elements can include decision-making processes, risk management strategies, clear roles and responsibilities, communication structures and processes, monitoring and controlling processes, and alignment with the organization’s strategy and objectives.
What is the role of the project governance board?
The project governance board monitors progress, makes key decisions, provides strategic direction, manages risks, helps resolve issues and ensures that the project aligns with the organization’s strategy.
How does a governance model facilitate risk management?
A governance model provides a framework for identifying, assessing, and managing risks, including the roles and responsibilities, reporting channels, risk assessment techniques and tools, and the process for managing identified risks.
What is the relationship between effective governance and resource management?
Effective governance ensures that resources are efficiently allocated, used, and managed. It provides a structure for making decisions about resource prioritization and use, based on the project’s strategic alignment and overall objectives.
How does project governance contribute to stakeholder management?
Project governance provides a clear framework for stakeholder identification, communication and engagement. It defines the roles and responsibilities of stakeholders, the process for addressing their concerns, and the strategy for managing their expectations and demands.
Can project governance prevent project failure?
Yes, effective project governance can prevent project failure by ensuring all decisions and processes align with the project’s objectives and organization’s strategy, and setting up procedures and controls to monitor project performance and address risks.
How does project governance ensure alignment with organizational strategy?
Project governance ensures alignment with organizational strategy by establishing a clear connection between the project’s goals and the wider organizational objectives. It guides decision-making and resource allocation to ensure that the project supports and contributes to the strategic direction of the organization.
Explain how project governance contributes to project success.
By providing an effective decision-making structure, clear roles and responsibilities, and processes for risk management, communication, and alignment with organizational goals, project governance reduces uncertainty and increases the probability of project success.
How should governance models be adapted for different types of projects?
Governance models should be tailored to each project’s specific needs, complexity, and risk profile. This can include variation in roles, decision-making structures, risk management strategies, and reporting procedures, depending on the unique context of each project.
How should we monitor and control projects within an established governance model?
It requires regular performance measurement, status reporting, risk assessment, and decision making. The results should be communicated effectively to all stakeholders, ensuring transparency, accountability, and alignment with the established governance model.
What benefits do the organizations perceive from an effective governance model?
An effective governance model enhances stakeholder confidence, improves decision making, promotes efficiency, enables better risk management, and optimizes resource allocation. It also aligns projects more closely with strategic objectives, increasing their contribution to organizational success.
How does transparency within the project governance framework influence project outcomes?
Transparency in project governance contributes to trust and accountability among project stakeholders, leading to a higher level of commitment, involvement, and cooperation. This in turn can increase the chances of project success, contribute to effective risk management, and enhance stakeholder satisfaction.
extutorials.com