Risk identification, evaluation, and allocation are critical components in the process of project management. These components gain even more importance in the context of construction projects due to the array of complexities, uncertainties, and variables that define the construction landscape. To that end, candidates preparing for the PMI Construction Professional (PMI-CP) exam should have a robust comprehension of these aspects to excel in the examination and their respective professional lives.
I. Risk Identification
Risk identification is the initial step in the risk management process, whereby potential risks are identified in advance. These could be uncertainties in schedules, budget, scope, human resources, equipment, materials, and safety that could negatively impact the project’s outcomes.
The process of risk identification includes:
- Documentation Review: Reviewing project’s estimate, schedule, contracts, and past experiences to identify risks.
- Brainstorming: Engaging the project’s team in brainstorming sessions to uncover possible risks based on their experience and expertise.
- Delphi Technique: Gathering feedback from subject matter experts anonymously to avoid any bias.
- SWOT analysis: Identifying risks based on the project’s Strength, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats.
II. Risk Evaluation
Risk evaluation typically follows risk identification and involves estimating the likelihood and impact of the identified risks on the project goals and deliverables.
The following steps are integral to risk evaluation:
- Probability Estimation: The chance of occurrence for each identified risk.
- Impact Analysis: The probable effect each risk will have on the project, should it occur.
- Risk Matrix: A grid that plots likelihood against impact and enables visual comparison and categorization of risks.
III. Risk Allocation
Risk allocation, also known as risk response planning, involves determining strategic responses to risks aiming to maximize opportunities and minimize threats. Activities in this process include avoidance, transfer, mitigation, and acceptance.
Common strategies associated with risk allocation are:
- Avoid: Altering the project plan to eliminate the risk or protect the project objectives from its impact.
- Transfer: Shifting the impact of the risk to a third party, often through contracts or insurance.
- Mitigate: Reducing the probability of occurrence or impact of a risk to an acceptable threshold.
- Acceptance: Accepting the risk and responding to it if it occurs, often used for lesser risks without a high impact or probability.
Risk management is an ongoing process that involves continuous monitoring and control to ensure that risk responses are effective. The importance of identifying, evaluating, and allocating risks in the construction landscape cannot be overstated, especially considering the high stakes and slim margins for error in construction projects.
Taking the PMI-CP exam will need a detailed understanding of these processes. This comprehensive understanding will enable candidates to manipulate the project landscape effectively and steer their projects away from potential obstacles and toward success.
However, the theoretical understanding of these concepts is not enough, and candidates should apply their knowledge to case studies and real-life examples to fully understand the applications and benefits of effective risk management. Candidates should make use out of every study resource available and practice these concepts across a wide range of construction contexts to ensure they are fully prepared for whatever the exam — or their professional lives — might throw at them.
Practice Test
True or False: Risk allocation is the process of assigning potential hazards or risks to various entities or individuals involved in a project.
Answer: True
Explanation: Risk allocation involves assigning the responsibility of potential risks to respective individuals or entities in a project. The purpose is to ensure that each risk is managed and mitigated effectively and efficiently.
In risk evaluation, which of the following factors are considered: (Select all that apply)
- a) Impact of the risk
- b) The probability of occurrence
- c) The cost of mitigation
- d) The health of the project manager
Answer: a, b, c
Explanation: Risk evaluation includes assessing the impact, probability of occurrence, and cost of mitigation. The health of a project manager, while important, is not typically a factor in risk evaluation.
Which of the following is NOT a step in the risk management process?
- a) Identifying risks
- b) Evaluating risks
- c) Allocating risks
- d) Ignoring risks
Answer: d. Ignoring risks
Explanation: Ignoring risks don’t contribute to effective risk management. Instead, it can lead to more severe consequences when the risk materializes.
True or False: Risk management is done once at the beginning of the project and does not require any further review.
Answer: False
Explanation: Risk management is a continuous process throughout the life of a project. Risks should be constantly identified, evaluated, managed and reviewed.
In risk allocation, the principle of ________________ states that the party who is best able to control the risk should bear the risk.
- a) Decentralization
- b) Centralization
- c) Equilibrium
- d) Pareto-efficiency
Answer: b) Centralization
Explanation: The principle of centralization in risk allocation is about assigning the risk to the party best able to control and manage the risk.
True or False: Involved stakeholders should not be included in identifying and evaluating risks.
Answer: False
Explanation: All pertinent stakeholders should be involved in all steps of risk management as they bring different perspectives which can be useful in identifying and evaluating risks.
Risk avoidance involves:
- a) Reducing the impact of a risk
- b) Accepting the risk
- c) Not taking action that would trigger a risk
- d) Transferring the risk to another party
Answer: c) Not taking action that would trigger a risk
Explanation: Risk avoidance involves not taking any actions that would lead to the risk occurring. It is about making alternative plans that do not involve the risk.
Which of the following is not a basic strategy for risk allocation?
- a) Retention
- b) Transfer
- c) Avoidance
- d) Aggravation
Answer: d) Aggravation
Explanation: Aggravation is not a risk allocation strategy. The basic risk allocation strategies are retention (holding onto the risk), transfer (shifting the risk to another party), and avoidance (changing plans to evade the risk).
True or False: All identified risks must be addressed immediately.
Answer: False
Explanation: Not all identified risks might need immediate attention, but they must be evaluated and prioritized based on their impact and probability.
The risk register is a document that:
- a) Contains details of all identified risks, their evaluation, and planned response
- b) A record of past risks and their impacts
- c) A list of potential risks that might occur in the future
- d) A document that shares risk information with stakeholders
Answer: a) Contains details of all identified risks, their evaluation, and planned response
Explanation: A risk register is a risk management tool that details all identified risks, including their severity, actions, and responsibilities for each risk.
Interview Questions
What are some examples of the types of risks you might identify during risk allocation in a PMI-CP exam?
Examples of risks identified could include schedule risks related to project deadlines, cost risks related to budget overruns, or performance risks related to the quality of the project’s output. Also, legal, operational, and reputational risks could be identified for better allocation.
Why is it vital to both identify and evaluate risks in a PMI-CP scenario?
Identifying and evaluating risks is essential for preemptive planning. By identifying potential hurdles, steps can be taken to either mitigate, eliminate, or prepare for these possible issues. This risk management strategy creates more resilient project plans.
What are the steps involved in effective risk management as per PMI Construction Professionals?
The steps for effective risk management include: risk identification, Risk Assessment/Evaluation, risk mitigation planning, risk mitigation plan implementation, and risk tracking.
How does understanding the difference between risk avoidance and risk management affect your role as a PMI construction professional?
Understanding the difference allows for more strategic planning; risk avoidance involves eliminating risk entirely, while risk management involves adopting strategies to mitigate the potential impact of the risk. Recognizing the right strategy to adopt per time will ensure optimal project delivery within scope, time, and cost.
How can you use a risk register in a PMI-CP project context?
Risk Register is a risk management tool that lists and classifies identified risks. It also includes an analysis of their potential impact and mitigation plans. In a PMI-CP project context, it serves as a dashboard for keeping track of all the project’s potential risks, their severity, and management plans.
What are common risk allocation strategies in construction management?
Common strategies include transferring the risk to another party, accepting the risk, mitigating the risk by implementing measures to reduce its impact or likelihood, or avoiding the risk by changing the project plan.
How would you assess the effectiveness of a risk response plan in a PMI-CP exam?
The effectiveness can be assessed by comparing the predicted outcomes with the actual outcomes. It could involve documenting the effectiveness of the actions taken, the timeliness of the response, and if, in the end, the risk was eliminated or reduced.
What is the purpose of stochastic risk analysis in the context of a PMI-CP exam?
Stochastic risk analysis allows for the quantification of uncertain scenarios in project risk management. It uses probability distributions to represent uncertainties and simulates possible project outcomes, essentially providing a range of possible project outcomes and not just best or worst-case scenarios.
Why is communication essential in risk management from a PMI-CP perspective?
Communication is vital as it ensures all stakeholders are aware of potential risks, understand the impact they could have on the project, and know what steps will be taken to mitigate any undesirable effects. It promotes transparency, inclusivity, and shared responsibility.
How does contingency strategy fit into risk management in a PMI-CP project context?
A contingency strategy is a plan B that takes effect when a risk materializes. It is a part of risk management as it enables the project to continue running despite facing identified risks. Contingency plans increase project resilience and reduce potential downtime.
In a PMI-CP context, how does risk assessment contribute to better risk allocation?
Risk assessment involves analyzing the identified risks to evaluate their potential impact and likelihood of occurrence. This information is crucial in deciding how to allocate resources or adjust project plans to deal with these potential problems. Good risk assessment can lead to optimal risk allocation.
What is the role of risk prioritizing in a PMI-CP project context?
Risk prioritization enables project managers to focus and allocate resources effectively and efficiently by addressing the most significant risks. This allows for a more strategic approach to risk management by focusing on those risks with the highest potential impact and likelihood of occurrence.
How can risk avoidance be a risky strategy in itself in a PMI-CP project context?
Risk avoidance often means changing project plans to prevent potential risks, but it could mean missing out on potential opportunities. It could also lead to a false sense of security, preventing the development of necessary risk management skills within the project team. Hence, it’s a strategy that must be used judiciously.
How does the identification and evaluation of risks contribute to the creation of a risk response plan?
Risk identification gives insight into what potential problems might arise, while risk evaluation provides guidance about where priorities should lie based on the potential impact of each risk. This forms the basis for developing effective responses tailored to meet the specific circumstances of identified and evaluated risks.
What steps can be taken to better manage identified risks in PMI-CP projects?
Steps to manage identified risks include establishing a risk management process, identifying and documenting risks, evaluating and ranking the risks, developing a risk response plan, monitoring and controlling the risks, and communicating risks and responses to stakeholders. A well-implemented risk management process ensures risks are proactively managed for better project results.
extutorials.com