Prioritization criteria are a critical part of the project and portfolio management process. As a portfolio manager or candidate preparing for the Portfolio Management Professional (PfMP) exam, identifying and using these criteria effectively is paramount in order to create a solid foundation for decision-making. These criteria may include legislative factors, dependencies, Return On Investment (ROI), stakeholder expectations, and strategic fit among others. This article will dive deep into these criteria, shedding light on how they can be identified using various information gathering and analysis techniques.
I. Legislative Factors
Legislative factors play a significant role in the prioritization process. These refer to all regulatory or legal obligations that a company needs to comply with. Non-adherence to these obligations can result in fines, penalties, or significant operational disruptions.
Techniques such as environmental scanning and legislative tracking can be used to gather information about relevant legislation. These will allow you to identify and understand the legislative factors that could affect your portfolio.
II. Dependencies
Dependencies refer to the interconnectedness of your projects and how the sequence or deliverables of one project can affect another. Understanding and highlighting these dependencies is important to effectively manage the portfolio and mitigate risk.
Techniques such as dependency mapping and task linking in project management systems can be employed to identify these. Analyzing project schedules, stakeholder interviews, and historical data can play a role as well.
III. Return on Investment (ROI)
ROI refers to the potential benefit (returns) an organization may gain as compared to the cost of the project.
This can be calculated using various financial analysis techniques such as financial modeling, cost-benefit analysis, and payback period analysis. A project with a higher ROI would logically be given priority over another with a lower ROI.
IV. Stakeholder Expectations
Another key area for prioritization is Stakeholder Expectations. Stakeholders may include internal executives, employees, investors, customers, among others. Their buy-in, support, and satisfaction are critical for project success.
Techniques to gather this data include surveys, interviews, and workshops. Stakeholder analysis and engagement planning can then be used to understand, analyze, and manage these expectations.
V. Strategic Fit
Finally, how well a project aligns with the company’s strategy, vision, and objectives is also used as a prioritization criterion. This is known as the strategic fit.
Techniques such as SWOT analysis, financial forecasting, and strategic planning can be used to identify, quantify and analyze the strategic fit of a project. Projects that better align with a company’s strategic goals are likely to get a higher prioritization.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the identification of prioritization criteria, such as legislative factors, dependencies, ROI, stakeholder expectations, and strategic fit, are key to effective portfolio management. Information gathering and analysis techniques provide the necessary tools to identify, quantify, and analyze these criteria in order to make informed decisions about which projects to prioritize for optimal portfolio performance. Therefore, mastering these criteria is not just key to passing the PfMP exam, but also to successfully managing real-world portfolios.
Practice Test
True or False: Stakeholder expectation is not relevant when identifying prioritization criteria.
- Answer: False.
Explanation: Stakeholder expectation is considered pivotal as it helps direct the development and implementation of strategies and ensures that they align with stakeholder needs and values.
Which among the following is not usually considered as a basis for decision making in portfolio management?
- a. Stakeholder expectations.
- b. Legislative priorities.
- c. Personal preferences.
- d. Return on Investment (ROI).
- Answer: c. Personal preferences.
Explanation: Personal preferences should not influence objective decision making in portfolio management. Factors such as legislative priorities, ROI and stakeholder expectations are critical considerations in decision making process.
The process of placing importance on certain criteria over others in order to make better decisions is referred to as…
- a. Prioritization
- b. Categorization
- c. Optimization
- d. Newmanization
- Answer: a. Prioritization.
Explanation: Prioritization is the process of determining and ranking the importance and urgency of tasks thus guiding decision making in portfolio management.
True or False: The strategic fit of a project is not a prioritization criterion.
- Answer: False.
Explanation: The strategic fit of project is indeed a common prioritization criterion. This pertains to how well a project aligns with the strategic goals and objectives of the organization.
In portfolio management, ROI stands for:
- a. Return of Instalment.
- b. Return on Investment.
- c. Rate of Interest.
- d. Regulation of Institutes.
- Answer: b. Return on Investment.
Explanation: ROI (Return on Investment) is a measure used to evaluate the efficiency or profitability of an investment.
Dependencies among projects or initiatives can:
- a. Make prioritization easier.
- b. Make prioritization more complex.
- c. Not affect prioritization.
- Answer: b. Make prioritization more complex.
Explanation: Dependencies between projects or initiatives can indeed make prioritization more complex, as the outcome or success of one project can rely on the execution of another.
Stakeholder expectations may include:
- a. Risk tolerance.
- b. Budget constraints.
- c. Timelines.
- d. All of the above.
- Answer: d. All of the above.
Explanation: Stakeholder expectations may encompass variety of aspects like risk tolerance, budget limits, timelines, and specific outcome expectations.
Legislative constraints:
- a. Can always be ignored when prioritizing projects.
- b. Often play a crucial role in project prioritization.
- c. Are unrelated to portfolio management.
- Answer: b. Often play a crucial role in project prioritization.
Explanation: Legislative constraints, such as regulatory compliance requirements, quite often are important considerations when prioritizing projects within a portfolio.
True or False: Information gathering and analysis techniques have little impact on prioritization criteria.
- Answer: False.
Explanation: Information gathering and analysis techniques have a significant impact on defining prioritization criteria; they let the decision-makers undertake informed decisions by unifying and making sense of data and information.
Prioritization criteria must be:
- a. Rigorously defined.
- b. Flexible.
- c. All of the above.
- Answer: c. All of the above.
Explanation: Whilst prioritization criteria should indeed be rigorously defined for clarity and consistency, there also needs to be a level of flexibility to allow for changes in strategy, stakeholder expectations, or external circumstances.
Interview Questions
What does ROI stand for, and how is it a prioritization criterion for decision making?
ROI stands for “Return on Investment”. As a prioritization criterion, it is used to evaluate the profitability of an investment or to compare the efficiency of different investments.
How does legislative criteria affect decision-making in portfolio management?
Legislative criteria refer to regulations and laws that a project or decision must comply with. These laws and regulations can dramatically affect both the feasibility and profitability of a project or decision.
What are dependencies and how do they play a role in setting prioritization criteria?
Dependencies refer to the reliance of one task or project on another. In setting prioritization criteria, the dependencies between different tasks or projects must be considered to ensure that all dependent tasks or projects are completed in the appropriate order.
How can stakeholder expectations be utilized as a prioritization criterion?
Stakeholder expectations refer to the desired outcomes of the stakeholders in the project. As a prioritization criterion, understanding and meeting these expectations can significantly contribute to the success and acceptance of a project.
What does the strategic fit criterion mean in the context of portfolio management?
Strategic fit refers to how well a particular project aligns with the organization’s overall strategy. The better the strategic fit, the higher the project should be prioritized.
What is the importance of information gathering and analysis techniques?
Information gathering and analysis techniques are crucial for determining the importance and priority of different tasks or projects. These techniques can provide a better understanding of the project’s situation, which will aid in the decision-making process.
What is the role of ROI in the decision making of portfolio management?
In portfolio management, ROI helps to measure the possible profits or losses that could be acquired from a project. It guides decision-making by helping to prioritize projects that can potentially provide the highest return.
How do strategic fit and stakeholder expectations inform the decision-making process?
Strategic fit informs decision-making by indicating which projects align most closely with the organization’s strategy. Stakeholder expectations inform the decision-making process by providing insight into the desired outcomes of the stakeholders, which can then be used to prioritize projects.
In what way can regulations and laws impact the prioritization of projects?
Regulations and laws can significantly affect the feasibility of a project. Compliance with these can necessitate a shift in resources, affecting the prioritization of various projects.
How can understanding dependencies create a basis for decision making?
Understanding dependencies can aid in scheduling and project planning. If some projects are dependent on others, they need to be scheduled accordingly, which will influence decision-making and project prioritization.
Why is it essential to analyze the ROI before taking any decision in portfolio management?
ROI analysis is essential as it provides insight into a project’s profitability. It aids in the prioritization of projects that promise higher returns, thus informing decision-making in portfolio management.
How do stakeholder expectations influence the decision-making process in portfolio management?
Stakeholder expectations guide the decision-making process as projects that meet these expectations tend to have higher acceptance rates. Therefore, it’s essential to align projects with stakeholder expectations to increase their success rate.
Can compliance with legislative criteria impact the ROI of a project?
Yes, compliance with legislative criteria can impact the ROI of a project. This can incur additional costs or delays that can reduce the ROI, thus impacting profitability.
Why is it important to consider the strategic fit of a project in decision-making in portfolio management?
Considering the strategic fit of a project is important as it ensures that a project aligns with the organization’s goals and strategies. Therefore, projects with a high strategic fit should be given priority in decision-making.
How are information gathering and analysis techniques used to develop prioritization criteria in portfolio management?
Information gathering and analysis techniques are used to obtain relevant data about different projects, such as their cost, estimated ROI, stakeholder expectations, strategic fit and more. This information then aids in forming a clear prioritization criterion for each project, thus facilitating more informed decision-making.
extutorials.com