Portfolio Management is a dynamic process, constantly subjected to the ever-changing business environment and competitive landscape. The selection of portfolio components, their prioritization, and related scenario development are integral tasks in the Portfolio Management Professional (PfMP) training and certification.
Criteria for Portfolio Prioritization
The first step in any portfolio management process is the identification of the criteria for the prioritization of projects. This could be based on a multitude of factors including business objectives, organizational strategies, resource availability, potential benefits, risks, interdependencies, market conditions etc.
One popular method used for prioritization is the scoring model wherein each project is rated based on predefined criteria. These scores are then added up to provide a total score for each project. Projects with the highest scores, assuming a higher score is better, are then prioritized.
Here is an example of a scoring model:
| Criteria | Project A | Project B | Project C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Business Value | 3 | 5 | 4 |
| Cost Efficiency | 5 | 3 | 4 |
| Risk Level | 4 | 2 | 3 |
| Total Score | 12 | 10 | 11 |
In this example, Project A stands as the highest priority, followed by Project C and Project B.
Portfolio Scenarios
Once the portfolio components have been decided and prioritized, the next step is to develop different portfolio scenarios. A portfolio scenario is an organized and integrated set of individual projects or components that collectively achieve an organizational objective.
The process involves structuring different combinations of projects considering their interdependencies, the organization’s strategic goals, the risk implications, and the resource capacity.
Rationale Behind Decision Making
The creation of portfolio scenarios and the prioritization of the components provide a sound basis for strategic decision making. Decision makers in the organization can weigh the expected benefits and risks of different scenarios against the resources required and the fulfillment of strategic objectives.
For instance, even if Project A scores the highest on the scale, executing it might require significant resources that the organization cannot afford at the moment. In contrast, Project C, despite scoring lower, might present a better cost-to-benefit ratio and align better with the organization’s current resource capacity and future strategic goals.
Conclusion
Drawing from this information, it can be concluded that prioritization analysis/criteria, coupled with the creation of portfolio scenarios, can dramatically aid in the governance of any organization. It assists in strategic planning and sound decision making, aiding an organization in achieving both its short-term and long-term objectives.
Moreover, it plays a vital role in ensuring the suitable allocation and utilization of organizational resources, facilitating the creation of a balanced portfolio that matches the organization’s strategic direction. This balance between risks, benefits, and resources is the key to successful portfolio management, a key competency that PfMP certification seeks to instill in professionals.
The realization of this balance forms the basis of the dynamic and robust process of portfolio management, making one knowledgeable and competent in maintaining an adaptive and resilient organization in the face of rapidly changing business environments.
Practice Test
True or False: Prioritization analysis is a mandatory step in developing portfolio scenarios.
- Answer: True
Explanation: Prioritization analysis helps in ranking the projects based on their strategic importance, risks, and expected returns. This helps in developing portfolio scenarios and making informed decisions.
In portfolio management, which among the following is considered as a criterion in prioritization analysis?
- a) Amount of potential risk involved
- b) Strategic importance
- c) Both a and b
- d) None of the above
Answer: c) Both a and b
Explanation: Both potential risk and strategic importance are key deciding factors in prioritization analysis while considering projects for portfolio management.
True or False: Related components of a portfolio do not play any role in prioritization analysis.
- Answer: False
Explanation: Related components such as potential risks, dependencies, resources involved, etc., significantly impact prioritization analysis.
Which of the following components of portfolio management helps in decision-making?
- a) Prioritization Analysis
- b) Risk Assessment
- c) Financial Analysis
- d) All of the above
Answer: d) All of the above
Explanation: All these components help in providing a comprehensive view of the portfolio and aid in informed decision-making.
True or False: The portfolio scenarios should always contain the highest priority projects.
- Answer: False
Explanation: High priority does not always mean it will fit the portfolio’s strategic goals. A balance of high and low priority projects based on various factors can create an effective portfolio scenario.
Portfolio governance is responsible for:
- a) Developing portfolio scenarios
- b) Prioritization analysis
- c) Making decisions based on prioritization analysis
- d) None of the above
Answer: c) Making decisions based on prioritization analysis
Explanation: Portfolio governance is responsible for decision-making, based on prioritization analysis done by portfolio managers.
The rationale for decision-making in portfolio management often includes:
- a) Benefits realization
- b) Resource allocation
- c) Cost management
- d) All of the above
Answer: d) All of the above
Explanation: These factors collectively provide a rationale for decisions such as prioritising projects or resources allocation etc., in portfolio management.
True or False: The sole purpose of portfolio management is to maximize financial returns.
- Answer: False
Explanation: While financial return is important, portfolio management also includes aligning projects with strategic goals, risk management, and effective resource allocation.
The primary purpose of prioritization analysis is:
- a) To maximize profits
- b) To minimize cost
- c) To help in decision-making
- d) None of the above
Answer: c) To help in decision-making
Explanation: The primary purpose of prioritization analysis is to provide a basis for decision-making considering various factors such as strategic alignment, risk, value, and more.
True or False: Portfolio scenarios should always align with the strategic goals of the organization.
- Answer: True
Explanation: Portfolio scenarios should always ensure that selected projects align with the strategic goals of the organization to provide the expected return and value.
Interview Questions
What is the purpose of prioritization in the portfolio management context?
Prioritization analysis in portfolio management is a systematic process of ranking the projects in the portfolio on the basis of their strategic value, risks, potential return on investment, available resources, and alignment with the business objectives. The importance of prioritization lies in its role in facilitating decision making and governance, ensuring that resources are optimally allocated and the portfolio is balanced in accordance to the strategic objectives.
What constitutes a portfolio scenario in portfolio management?
A portfolio scenario refers to a set of potential situations or proposed portfolio variations that may be realized based on certain identified variables or factors. These scenarios can include potential changes in resource allocation, risk exposure, and strategic alignment. They are used to evaluate potential responses and outcomes to changes in the business environment or strategic objectives.
Why is it essential to provide governance with a rationale for decision-making in portfolio management?
Providing governance with a rationale for decision-making ensures transparency and ensures that all decisions align with business strategies and objectives. It allows for constructive dialogue and consensus building among stakeholders. The rationale also provides a record of the decision-making process, which can be useful for future reference, audits, and lessons-learned analysis.
What criteria can be used for prioritizing projects in a portfolio?
Various criteria can be used for prioritizing projects, such as strategic alignment, cost-benefit analysis, risk assessment, resource availability, stakeholder buy-in, regulatory compliance, and market conditions. The chosen criteria should match the organization’s strategic objectives and operational capacity.
How does portfolio scenario analysis contribute to prioritization and decision-making?
Portfolio scenario analysis allows for multiple potential outcomes to be evaluated before a decision is made. It provides insights into how changes in one or more variables might impact the portfolio and supports in ranking the projects based on their expected value and risk. This systematic approach helps in making well-informed and rational decisions.
What should be the action when the prioritization analysis indicates a project does not align with the organization’s strategic objectives?
If a project doesn’t align with the organization’s strategic objectives, it should be re-evaluated, paused, or even terminated. A lower-priority project that matches organizational strategies may even be promoted to replace it.
How can risks be mitigated when dealing with portfolio scenarios?
Risks can be mitigated through adequate planning, oversight, and control measures. These can include a robust risk assessment process, designing risk responses strategies, diversification of projects, and maintaining adequate contingency reserves.
Who is typically responsible for creating portfolio scenarios and related components?
The responsibility is typically given to Portfolio Managers, with the support of the Portfolio Management Office (PMO). All scenarios should be created in collaboration with project managers and key stakeholders to ensure all relevant factors are taken into consideration.
What is the role of governance in the portfolio management?
Governance in portfolio management provides oversight and guidance to the portfolio, upholding organizational strategies and ensuring that the portfolio is managed in an ethical, transparent, and accountable manner. It involves decision-making regarding the portfolio composition, prioritization, risk management, and resource allocation.
What can be the potential consequence of poor prioritization in portfolio management?
Poor prioritization can lead to sub-optimal resource allocation, higher risks, and probable failure to achieve desired business outcomes. It can lead to less crucial projects taking precedence over the highest strategic value projects. This can result in decreased ROI and can reduce the value that the portfolio would otherwise bring to the organization.
extutorials.com