Comprehensive conflict resolution solutions are hence needed to manage such conflicts and ensure the successful completion of the project. As guiding principles, the Project Management Professional (PMP) framework recommends various options to handle these situations, which will be evaluated and compared in this article.
1. Conflict Resolution Techniques
The PMP framework recommends five principal conflict resolution techniques:
- a) Problem Solving
- b) Compromising
- c) Forcing
- d) Avoiding
- e) Smoothing
Problem-solving, also known as confronting or collaborating, is considered the best conflict resolution technique. The involved parties openly discuss their viewpoints and solutions so that a consensus is reached. Though it could be time-consuming, it often brings the most satisfactory solution for all parties.
Compromising entails all parties giving up something in order to make an agreement. It’s faster than problem-solving, but not all parties might be completely satisfied because they had to give up something.
Forcing, as its name suggests, is where one party imposes its viewpoint on others, which can cause resentments and risk recurring conflicts in the future.
Avoiding is an approach where the conflict is neglected or postponed. This approach is typically used when the conflict is trivial or when there’s a high potential for escalation.
Smoothing, or accommodating, focuses on highlighting commonalities between the conflicting parties to reduce the importance of differences. However, it might not address the root cause of the conflict, posing a risk of recurring conflicts.
2. Conflict Resolution Selection
Not every technique is suitable for every situation, and successful conflict resolution requires analysing the situation and selecting the most appropriate technique.
| Problem Solving | Compromising | Forcing | Avoiding | Smoothing | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Resolution Duration | Long | Medium | Short | N/A | Short |
| Satisfaction Level | High | Medium | Low | N/A | Low |
| Recurrence Possibility | Low | Medium | High | High | High |
The table above outlines the impact each method has on resolution duration, satisfaction level, and the possibility of recurrence.
Here is an example: Suppose a project team has a disagreement about the project’s schedule. If it’s a minor disagreement, compromising might be a good approach; everyone gives up a bit, and you will have a resolution relatively quickly. But if it’s a significant disagreement that threatens the project timeline, problem-solving might be better. It will take longer, but it’ll end up with an optimal resolution that everyone agrees with, and the conflict is unlikely to recur.
However, If the disagreement involves crucial aspects such as project design or quality, forcing might be required. Though it could lead to resentment from the losing side, the project needs to maintain its quality or adhere to the design to meet project objectives.
3. Conflict Resolution Management
The PMP exam emphasizes conflict management’s role within the broader framework of project management. Typically, it’s the project manager’s responsibility to manage conflicts, but the best conflict resolution starts even before a conflict arises. This can be achieved by setting ground rules at the beginning of a project, encouraging open communication, and creating an environment that fosters collaboration and mutual respect.
It’s also crucial to remember the importance of communication and negotiation skills in conflict resolution. The Project Management Institute (PMI) states that a project manager spends 90% of their time communicating, and much of that communication involves negotiation, even indirectly, in resolving conflicting priorities, resource competition, and different work styles.
Conflict resolution isn’t just about resolving the conflict at hand; it’s also about learning from it to avoid similar conflicts in the future. Regularly revisiting and, if necessary, revising conflict management techniques and strategies is an essential part of continuous improvement in project management.
In conclusion, while conflicts are unavoidable in project management, they can be managed effectively by understanding and applying the right conflict resolution techniques. With appropriate conflict resolution management and a continuous learning mindset, project managers can turn conflicts from project threats into opportunities for team growth and project success.
Practice Test
True or False: Project managers should avoid conflicts at all costs.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: Conflicts are inevitable in any project. A good project manager should not avoid conflicts but rather learn how to manage and resolve them effectively.
In a conflict situation, the project manager should always:
- a) Side with the team member they like best
- b) Ignore the conflict and hope it will resolve itself
- c) Actively seek a resolution
- d) Let the team resolve the conflict themselves
Answer: c) Actively seek a resolution
Explanation: The project manager has a responsibility to manage conflicts within the team and seek resolutions to maintain a positive working environment.
True or False: When it comes to conflict resolution, collaboration is not ideal because it takes too much time.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: Collaboration may take longer but it results in a win-win situation as it involves getting to a solution that satisfies all parties.
In terms of conflict resolution, when is it most appropriate to use the avoiding strategy?
- a) When the issue is unimportant
- b) When the team is under high stress
- c) When the issue is critical to project success
- d) When the team members are in agreement
Answer: a) When the issue is unimportant
Explanation: The avoiding strategy can be used when the issue at hand is trivial or when there’s potential for a more useful opportunity to be lost if time is wasted on this less important conflict.
True or False: One of the primary roles of a Project Manager is to anticipate conflicts before they arise.
- True
- False
Answer: True.
Explanation: The ability to foresee and deal with potential disputes before they escalate is a crucial part of successful project management.
What is the first step in conflict resolution?
- a) Mediation
- b) Defining the conflict
- c) Seeking external help
- d) Escalation to senior management
Answer: b) Defining the conflict
Explanation: Before any conflict can be resolved, it must be clearly defined and understood by all parties involved.
Select the strategies for conflict resolution. (Multiple Answers)
- a) Avoiding
- b) Ignoring
- c) Collaborating
- d) Compromising
- e) Forcing
Answer: a) Avoiding, c) Collaborating, d) Compromising, e) Forcing
Explanation: Except ignoring, all are recognized strategies for conflict resolution, each with its own appropriate use depending on the situation.
True or False: The objective of conflict resolution is to suppress the conflict.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: The objective of conflict resolution is not to suppress the conflict but to find a constructive solution that is in the best interest of the project.
Which conflict resolution technique is most beneficial in the long term?
- a) Smoothing
- b) Withdrawing
- c) Collaborating
- d) Forcing
Answer: c) Collaborating
Explanation: Collaborating addresses the root cause of the conflict providing a long term solution. Other techniques often provide just a short-term relief.
True or False: Project Management success can be achieved without effective conflict resolution strategies.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: Conflict resolution is an integral part of project management as it helps maintain a healthy team dynamic and ensures smooth progress towards project objectives.
Project managers need to reconcile conflicts to_____.
- a) Assert authority
- b) Ensure a happy team
- c) Keep senior management happy
- d) Maintain project productivity and success
Answer: d) Maintain project productivity and success
Explanation: Effective conflict resolution is key to maintaining productivity and the overall success of the project.
True or False: It is essential to get to the root cause of a conflict for effective resolution.
- True
- False
Answer: True.
Explanation: By understanding the root cause of conflict, project managers can provide long-lasting solutions and prevent similar conflicts in the future.
Collaborating resolution strategy can also be termed as_____.
- a) Lose-lose
- b) Win-win
- c) Win-lose
- d) Lose-win
Answer: b) Win-win
Explanation: In a collaborating resolution strategy, the input from all parties involved leading to a satisfactory resolution for everyone, hence creating a win-win situation.
True or False: For a project manager, resolving conflicts is a one-time activity.
- True
- False
Answer: False.
Explanation: As long as the project is running, the possibility of conflicts keeps coming up. So, conflict resolution is an ongoing activity for a project manager.
In conflict management, forcing or directing is a technique that is _____.
- a) Informal
- b) Win-lose
- c) Win-win
- d) Lose-lose
Answer: b) Win-lose
Explanation: Forcing or directing, is a strategy where a project manager imposes a decision, which leads to a win-lose situation. This strategy is mostly used in case of urgent decisions.
Interview Questions
What are some effective conflict resolution techniques recommended for project management?
Some effective strategies include accommodating, avoiding, collaborating, compromising, and competing.
What does accommodating as a conflict management technique involve?
Accommodating involves forgetting one’s own needs to maintain peace in the project team. It is useful when the issue at hand is more important to others than to you.
How does the compromising technique help in conflict management?
Compromising is often seen as a democratic resolution technique. It involves finding a mutually acceptable solution that partially satisfies everyone.
Can you explain when the avoiding conflict resolution technique can be appropriate?
The avoiding conflict resolution technique can be appropriate when a conflict is trivial, there’s no chance of winning, stakes are high and a delay is necessary, or others can solve the issue more effectively.
What is meant by competing as a conflict resolution strategy in project management?
Competing is a power-oriented strategy where one person seeks to fulfill their own interests at the expense of others. This strategy can become destructive if overused, especially when a collaborative solution is the best way forward.
In what situations is the collaborating resolution technique most effective?
Collaboration is most effective when the future relations with the conflicting party are important, and both parties are committed to the project’s goal. It’s also useful when you want to integrate different viewpoints into a consensus and gain commitment by incorporating everyone’s perspective.
How does one decide which conflict resolution technique to use in a given situation?
The choice of conflict management technique depends on the urgency of the conflict, power dynamics among team members, and the potential impact of the conflict on the project.
What role does conflict play in project management?
Conflict can be positive as it encourages diversity of thought and fosters a more thorough decision-making process. However, if left unresolved it can lead to team dysfunction and delay project delivery.
Could you elaborate on how the Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument (TKI) can aid in conflict resolution for project management?
The Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument (TKI) is a model that identifies a range of conflict styles including competing, accommodating, avoiding, collaborating and compromising. It serves as a guide for project managers to handle and resolve conflicts based on their analysis of the situation.
If a project manager encounters a conflict between two team members, what should be his/her first step?
The initial step should be to understand the cause and nature of the conflict. This can involve facilitating a discussion between the two team members to understand their perspectives and needs.
How important is communication in conflict resolution within a project management scope?
Communication is crucial in conflict resolution. Encouraging open and honest communication can help team members express their concerns and expectations, rendering it easier to identify solutions that satisfy all parties involved.
How can a project manager foster a constructive environment for conflict resolution?
A project manager can foster a constructive environment for conflict resolution by promoting open and respectful communication, establishing clear team roles and responsibilities, and treating each conflict as an opportunity for growth and improvement.
How critical is it to timely address conflicts in project management?
Timely resolution of conflicts is extremely important in project management. Unresolved conflicts can lead to team disintegration, stress, and delays in project execution.
How can project managers prevent conflicts proactively?
Project managers can proactively prevent conflicts by establishing clear roles and responsibilities, setting clear objectives, promoting healthy and respectful communication, managing team expectations, and harnessing diversity and differences in a positive manner.
Are there tools that can help project managers in conflict resolution?
Yes, there are several tools like CliftonStrengths, the Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument (TKI), and the Conflict Resolution Framework that can help project managers in conflict resolution.
extutorials.com